Price:

Microsoft’s buyout offer puts AI’s labor costs in view

Nov 3, 2026Summary from 5 podcasts.
  • Microsoft offered voluntary buyouts to as many as 60,000 employees, with savings tied to AI investment.
  • The hosts differed on whether the offer signals near-term job replacement or a broader shift in how companies staff work.

On Oct. 27, Microsoft offered voluntary buyouts to as many as 60,000 employees, about a quarter of its global workforce. The company’s executives tied the savings to funding AI investment. That is the number targeted by the offer, not a report that 60,000 people have been laid off.

On Hard Fork, Aaron Griffith said Microsoft expected only 3% to 5% of eligible workers to accept, or roughly 3,000 at most. She placed the offer amid years of tech-sector downsizing and questioned the company’s claim that buyouts give workers more control.

Alex Wissner-Gross, on Moonshots with Peter Diamandis, read the move less as direct replacement of software engineers than as a way to shift money from payroll into data centers. This Week in AI’s host saw a different signal: as AI tools improve, companies may keep headcount steady while needing fewer conventional jobs.

The concern extends beyond Microsoft. Breaking Points’ hosts cited Goldman Sachs analysis linking regular workplace AI adoption with weaker employment growth and higher unemployment. They focused especially on entry-level roles that help people learn how to work, which could disappear without showing up clearly in unemployment figures.

The buyout offer does not show how many workers will leave, or how many jobs AI has already replaced. But the shows’ debate points to the larger question behind it: whether the productivity gains from AI will create new work, or let companies get by with fewer people.

Source Intelligence

- Deep dive into what was said in the episodes

Ten31 Timestamp: The S-1 Also Rises • Nov 2

  • The guest argues that AI returns are becoming measurable beyond technology companies. Microsoft planned buyouts or cuts affecting roughly 60,000 employees, about a quarter of its global workforce, while executives tied the savings to funding AI investment.
Also discussed on this episode: (15)

Enterprise (2)

  • Anthropic’s S-1 showed substantial profitability and enterprise adoption: the company reported nearly $1 billion in GAAP operating income in Q2, with almost 12,000 customers spending over $100,000 annually.
  • Anthropic’s amended S-1 reported Q3 revenue of about $17 billion, up 1,127% year over year, and nine-month revenue of $33.2 billion; it also disclosed $895.4 billion in cumulative compute purchase and lease commitments.

AI Infrastructure (3)

  • The guest says the $895.4 billion commitment figure overstates firm liabilities because agreements vary in timing and can depend on compute providers meeting performance conditions; even a fraction would still represent a major capital burden.
  • Anthropic expects to spend more than $800 billion on computing infrastructure through 2045, and Blackstone reportedly expects a high-junk credit rating after the IPO rather than an immediate investment-grade rating. The guest says stronger cash flow could eventually lower financing costs.
  • The four major hyperscalers turned free-cash-flow negative as AI spending rose, even as Q3 U.S. GDP growth reached 3.4% and manufacturing PMIs hit their highest level since May 2022. Publicly held U.S. debt also crossed 100% of GDP.

Models (2)

  • Anthropic allocated 72% of first-half compute to training, research, and internal use, while 25% served paying customers. The guest says shifting training capacity to inference could quickly increase supply, while falling token prices require much faster user growth.
  • The guest sees frontier labs moving toward internal drug discovery and other vertical businesses, where they could capture value from their strongest models directly. Partnerships or joint ventures may limit channel conflict with customers that rely on the same labs for tokens.

Markets (1)

  • Markets punished crowded AI-related positions as expectations met execution risk: Intel suffered its worst single-day move since 1974, and Morgan Stanley data showed the largest recorded monthly hedge-fund reduction in exposure during October.

Big Tech (1)

  • Google’s AI search mode may monetize less effectively than traditional search, while Reddit’s CEO cited search-related traffic concerns. Marty Bent sees Meta’s ad targeting and user engagement as a potential advantage over Google’s search advertising.

Elections (1)

  • Brazil’s election result reversed a market rally driven by expectations of a Bolsonaro win: Lula prevailed, Bolsonaro left the country, and Brazil’s ETF and equities sold off. The guest says Lula’s win complicates U.S. efforts to counter China’s growing regional influence.

Diplomacy (1)

  • The guest says U.S. access to Brazilian rare-earth minerals and broader efforts to strengthen ties across Latin America now face a political setback. Trump’s suggestion that Venezuela could become a prosperous 51st state showed the administration’s continuing interest in the region.

Custody (1)

  • Binance reported a $6.3 billion theft after a North Korean spy allegedly socially engineered an engineer and accessed a laptop, enabling withdrawals across multiple chains. Binance paused withdrawals, set aside $6.34 billion to cover losses, and later reopened withdrawals.

BTC Markets (1)

  • The Binance attackers reportedly swept 18,000 bitcoin and other assets, then used stablecoins in DeFi to borrow ETH and Solana before stablecoin freezes blocked that route. The guest notes Bitcoin fell below $77,000 but remained above a key long-term moving average, echoing past exchange shocks that preceded a market bottom.

Protocol (1)

  • The guest argues Bitcoin’s limited protocol surface reduces security risk compared with chains built around more complex smart-contract systems. The Binance attack reportedly used Ethereum’s EIP-7702 delegation feature, which lets ordinary accounts act like smart contracts.

Coding (1)

  • A Coinbase exercise pointed frontier AI models at Bitcoin Core for weeks and produced two minor bugs, both since patched. The guest says the result reinforces Bitcoin’s status as a heavily reviewed codebase with a comparatively small attack surface.

Making Sense of This Week’s AI Market Crashes | #x307 • Oct 31

  • Alex interpreted Microsoft’s voluntary employee-exit offer as a way to shift cash from payroll operating expenses toward data-center capital spending, rather than straightforward AI substitution for software engineers. Dave expected sharp stock volatility for AI companies as each model release and benchmark changes investor expectations.
Also discussed on this episode: (22)

Startups (1)

  • A Pirates Labs contact said a pure graphene sheet thicker than a millimeter would be extraordinarily valuable; another speaker claimed access to a major graphene manufacturer but could not recall its name.

BTC Markets (1)

  • Salem called Chamath’s claim that Bitcoin is capped, has a limited buyer pool, and will eventually be hacked and go to zero a “scop.” Immad said AI and quantum computing could enable attacks, but Bitcoin could upgrade and retain buyers as a historic asset.

Custody (1)

  • The panel described a $6.3 billion Binance theft, allegedly enabled by attackers linked to North Korea compromising one engineer’s machine; the funds were moved in 20 minutes, and about $3 billion was reportedly frozen. Tether and Circle could freeze some stolen stablecoins, while public transaction trails made the transfers traceable.

Banking (1)

  • Immad compared the exchange breach with Bangladesh losing $100 million through a SWIFT transfer after an attacker impersonated a central-bank official. He warned that increasingly convincing AI-driven impersonation attacks could target both crypto users and traditional banks.

Media (1)

  • The panel remembered Patrick Stewart, who the host said had died at 86, and praised his portrayal of Captain Jean-Luc Picard. Alex suggested the character would persist through repeated fan and AI recreations.

Models (3)

  • Google’s Gemini 4 Carbon reportedly found 88% of vulnerabilities on SEC Bench Pro, exploited 55% of flaws on Exploit Bench, and wrote working patches for 71%. Alex said the model was not generally available and its benchmark position could reflect higher reasoning costs rather than a clear capability lead.
  • Google’s Genie 4 generates interactive 3D environments with sound, simulated physics, and real-time prompt-based changes. The panel saw uses in games, robot training, factory simulation, construction planning, and visual management, while Peter estimated current operation at $20 an hour and predicted $2 an hour next year.
  • Sam Altman said OpenAI spent hundreds of millions of dollars on mathematical research, with one proof costing around $10 million and later attempts costing less. Alex speculated that unpublished results could include Yang-Mills work, further Millennium problems, or cryptographic advances; panelists described the researchers’ excitement and sadness at a field-changing breakthrough.

Big Tech (1)

  • Immad predicted search advertising would peak in Q1 as customers increasingly buy through agents, challenging Google’s and Meta’s core business models. Alex said Alphabet could become more of a cloud company, while the panel noted Google’s advantage in TPUs, data, cash flow, and investments across AI companies.

Physics (1)

  • Alex argued that physics research should make falsifiable predictions grounded in the physical world, criticizing work that does not attempt to do so. He said his early chain theory leaves the simulation hypothesis untestable, while Immad argued AI could weaken peer review’s gatekeeping and make scientific ideas compete more openly.

Markets (1)

  • Alphabet shares fell 13% and lost $500 billion in market value despite revenue growth and a billion Gemini users; the panel pointed to weaker search growth and a $9 billion free-cash-flow burn. Dave argued that hyperscalers are borrowing heavily for AI while chip and memory shortages raise costs across consumer electronics.

AI Infrastructure (1)

  • Sam Altman said OpenAI is developing robots to build data centers, framing self-replicating infrastructure as a route to more compute. Alex argued lunar facilities could avoid terrestrial permitting resistance; Dave said data centers could make host regions wealthy, while the panel debated whether governments or AI systems would regulate them.

Robotics (2)

  • Tesla said Optimus production is starting at Fremont, with a line designed for one million robots a year and first customer deliveries expected in 2027. The panel disputed how quickly demand would extend beyond factories, while Immad argued that robots could become valuable assets as software improves and Dave saw industrial construction as an early market.
  • Immad argued that biological dogs retain advantages in endurance and adaptation, while mechanical dogs offer upgradeable software and repeatable production. The panel also discussed Elon Musk’s interest in longevity and Peter’s report of promising work at Isomorphic Labs, without detailing the underlying research.

Autonomous Vehicles (2)

  • The panel compared Tesla’s projected Cybercab cost of 20 cents per mile with Waymo’s newer service at 40 cents and its older version at $16. Waymo reportedly had 4,000 driverless vehicles, 500,000 paid weekly rides, and service in 15 cities; speakers said chip supply, maintenance, and real-world operating costs will determine the contest.
  • Cambridge Teamsters and transit workers asked local officials to block driverless taxis, citing jobs and safety. Panelists compared the resistance with Britain’s Red Flag Act and New York elevator-operator strikes, and argued autonomous vehicles could improve safety and lower travel costs despite labor disruption.

Education (1)

  • Computer science enrollment fell, and US full-time MBA applications dropped after two years of growth; panelists said students fear AI will reduce entry-level jobs. Salem argued universities should become entrepreneurship institutes, while Dave and Peter emphasized building, networks, and purpose over credentials alone.

Brain (1)

  • Peter said Fountain Life found that 45% of dementia cases are preventable through lifestyle, and that 46% of members with advanced brain age improved after 13 months of lifestyle support. The panel also discussed purpose after work disappears, while Peter cited Elon Musk’s growing interest in longevity and GLP-1 drugs.

Digital Sovereignty (1)

  • Anduril and Qualcomm announced Blue Chip, a rugged US-designed computer for military, government, and emergency users. Palmer Luckey said about 90% of parts came from the US or allies, with a target of 100%; the laptop costs about 20% more than high-end PCs, and its screen remains made in China.

Enterprise (1)

  • Salem said organizations should keep security rules, permissions, records, and compliance obligations above individual AI models so providers can be swapped without losing institutional accountability. He described machine-readable governance as necessary because models are changing every week or two.

China (1)

  • Immad attributed lower Chinese AI prices to compute constraints that encouraged efficient model design, distillation, and strong inference engineering, alongside lower research costs and thinner margins. Dave warned that stacked margins at TSMC, Nvidia, and model providers may compress as companies design chips and build fabs themselves.

Religion (1)

  • Salem argued that religions across traditions have used forced conversion and cited Christian inquisitions, Muslim persecution, Tibetan Buddhist suppression of Bon practitioners, and coercion under the Hasmonean kingdom. He said he intended to criticize all religions equally, then noted that roughly two-thirds of the world identifies as religious.
Hard Fork
Hard Fork

Casey Newton

Are We in an A.I. Bubble? We're About to Find Out. • Oct 30

  • Aaron Griffith says Microsoft offered buyouts to 60,000 employees, but expected only 3% to 5% to accept, or roughly 3,000 people at most. She connects the cuts to years of tech-sector downsizing and Microsoft’s AI and infrastructure spending, while criticizing the company’s claim that buyouts give workers more control.
Also discussed on this episode: (17)

Markets (4)

  • Aaron Griffith says Anthropic’s S-1 gives public investors their first full view of a frontier LLM company’s business, after years of private valuations and heavy investment across the AI economy.
  • Aaron Griffith says Anthropic reported an $80 billion net loss because convertible debt was counted as a loss, while its actual operating loss narrowed sharply year over year. The filing puts first-half 2026 revenue at $16.3 billion.
  • Aaron Griffith says investors will look for Anthropic’s next growth engine beyond coding, including drug development and legal technology. The IPO roadshow will give the company a chance to explain whether slower growth reflects competition or weaker demand across the AI market.
  • Aaron Griffith says the IPO will test private-market AI valuations against public investors’ financial models, though Wall Street can also be driven by hype and momentum. The opening voiceover framed a possible $100 billion raise at a $2 trillion valuation, with much less fundraising potentially rattling markets.

AI Infrastructure (1)

  • Anthropic’s growth depends on whether demand can justify its long-term, often non-cancellable commitments to data centers, chips, and compute. Aaron Griffith says Claude Code drove explosive first-half growth, but Q3 growth slowed to 44% as competitors gained ground and customers cut token spending.

Safety (4)

  • Anthropic’s S-1 lists catastrophic or existential harm from advanced AI among its risks, while using passive language that does not directly state the company itself holds that view. It also says model welfare could delay retiring older models, reflecting the company’s unusual concern about possible model sentience.
  • Aaron Griffith traces Anthropic’s founding to safety-focused researchers who left OpenAI, after earlier founders had split from Google over concerns about AI’s effects on humanity. Anthropic initially attracted money from Sam Bankman-Fried and other investors tied to effective altruism before enterprise software sales drew broader venture capital.
  • Mike Isaac says the PHP vulnerability exposed how widely internet infrastructure depends on old code that can contain serious flaws. AI tools can find vulnerabilities faster, but Isaac doubts defenders will keep pace; Max Reed cites Joshua Sachs’s argument that defenders still have time to strengthen systems before criminals adapt.
  • Jasmine Sun says a startup called Cathedral, staffed by former DOGE workers, accessed Anthropic’s Slack and IT systems and obtained trade secrets. The breach showed that even AI companies with advanced cyber models can leave their own internal systems exposed.

Startups (1)

  • Anthropic’s founders retain unusually strong control through five stock classes, a majority voting stake, and an independent trust that controls most board seats. Jasmine Sun says the founders pledged most of their equity to charity, while Anthropic’s culture-fit interview asks employees whether they would work there if their equity became worthless.

Elections (2)

  • Jasmine Sun says data centers drew bipartisan public opposition but rarely ranked among voters’ top concerns, limiting their influence on most major races. She reported stronger local effects, including recall efforts and city-council changes, and said rural voters could matter in a few close contests.
  • Jasmine Sun says Republican voters broadly favor slower AI deployment with safeguards, while party leaders have largely followed Donald Trump’s deregulatory line. She sees a possible post-midterm split between free-market Republicans and new-right groups advocating rules on children, jobs, and safety.

Big Tech (1)

  • Mike Isaac expects technology companies to elevate staff who can build ties with Democrats if Democrats gain power, after years of firms cultivating Republican relationships. Jasmine Sun says the cultural shift among venture capitalists appears limited, especially around issues such as DEI.

Regulation (1)

  • Aaron Griffith says California Proposition 40 would impose a one-time 5% tax on billionaires’ wealth, including unrealized gains and private startup shares. Opponents raised $333 million to defeat it, arguing the measure is poorly designed and could discourage founders, while some health groups question its long-term funding plan.

Coding (1)

  • Mike Isaac says an Amazon engineering memo rejected token use and lines of code as measures of software productivity, calling instead for evaluation based on long-term outcomes. Isaac notes that long-term results are difficult to measure in quarterly employment reviews, leaving the company without an easy replacement metric.

Models (1)

  • Jasmine Sun describes an Anthropic randomized trial in which professional statistical analysts often followed AI recommendations and reused AI arguments to justify their choices, while rarely admitting influence. Sun warns that people may quietly outsource decisions to AI without recognizing how much the systems shape their judgment.

VC (1)

  • Aaron Griffith says Andreessen Horowitz renamed its crypto fund A16Z Frontier, a sign that venture firms are broadening their mandates as AI absorbs most startup funding. She says crypto funds face fewer investable companies because builders have shifted toward AI, while the firm denies abandoning crypto.

Anthropic’s Money Machine, “Slop” Degrees & the Meat Proxy | TWiAI Ep 37 • Oct 29

  • The host linked AI productivity to Microsoft’s offer of buyouts to 60,000 employees and argued that companies may hold headcount steady as AI tools improve. The host urged children to learn entrepreneurship and predicted fewer conventional jobs; Andy Burman questioned whether college remains worth its cost.
Also discussed on this episode: (15)

Markets (4)

  • Anthropic’s S1 reported $16.3 billion in revenue for the first half of 2026, up from $1.2 billion a year earlier, and $1.6 billion in operating profit on an adjusted basis. A $72.4 billion non-cash charge tied to convertible notes drove the reported $80.7 billion net loss.
  • The host said Anthropic began generating revenue in 2023 and traced rapid growth from $40 million that year to $386 million in 2024 and $4.5 billion in 2025. The S1 also cited roughly 900% net revenue retention and about 200 to 250 customers paying more than $10 million annually.
  • The host said Anthropic was reportedly targeting a public listing the week of November 16, seeking as much as $100 billion or more at a $1.5 trillion to $2 trillion valuation. The S1 listed model shutdown resistance, catastrophic incidents, compute access, and selective government targeting among its risks.
  • John Nay said model labs may expand beyond token billing through outcome-based pricing or businesses built on top of their models. He cited charging for completed customer conversations as one possible structure, while noting that outcome pricing remains early even in application software.

AI Infrastructure (1)

  • Andy Burman identified compute supply as a core constraint for model labs, with Anthropic and OpenAI competing to secure capacity from a limited set of providers. He said Anthropic’s profitability makes its business look stronger, while its IPO pricing will test investor appetite amid pressure on neoclouds.

Enterprise (2)

  • Andy Burman expects token prices and the cost of intelligence to keep falling, while arguing that agent deployments can sharply increase usage. He said many large companies still lack connections between models and business data, leaving employees with basic email and document use rather than workflow-level automation.
  • Andy Burman called people who pass AI output along without adding judgment “meat proxies” and said workers should be able to defend their reasoning and deliverables. The host described timed, recorded research exercises and paired work as ways to test whether employees understand and can improve AI-generated results.

Agents (3)

  • Andy Burman said tool access and relevant company data determine whether agents produce useful work; models alone cannot deliver expected returns. He expects fleets of agents to handle business goals over time, but estimated self-driving companies could take two to ten years to emerge.
  • The host described using an agent connected to Slack, Notion, and calendars to identify unfinished assignments and surface missed work. Andy Burman said connecting tools and resources increases token use, but the return comes when agents can act on company data rather than merely generate polished messages.
  • The host argued that agent platforms could make AI mainstream among nontechnical users after building an Austin home-search database from brokers’ social media and video listings. Andy Burman said browser use had become capable of handling tasks across desktop and SaaS applications, though platform restrictions can block actions.

Education (2)

  • Alpha School promises computer-based academics in the morning and afternoons for life skills, but a New York Times review found many students missed its doubled-growth target. John Nay said the model may suit self-directed students, while the host warned that high tuition and selective enrollment make early results hard to generalize.
  • The host argued that AI-generated schoolwork can weaken writing, reading comprehension, and independent thought when students copy outputs without engaging with them. John Nay said education should emphasize philosophical reasoning and durable human skills as digital intelligence becomes cheap.

Open Source (1)

  • Reddit’s r/opensource moderators barred projects that use, are made by, or are intended for AI, and restricted posts to projects at least a year old with multiple contributors. John Nay linked the backlash to anxiety over changing software work; Andy Burman said open source has increasingly served as a product-shipping channel for AWS.

Labor (1)

  • John Nay said AI could move lawyers from routine document work toward advising clients on strategy and deal scenarios. Andy Burman expects fewer junior hires and a higher bar for entry-level roles, with verbal communication increasingly valuable; the host argued that human judgment and taste still shape AI’s drafts.

Philosophy (1)

  • The panel connected AI’s progress in mathematics and writing to questions of purpose: a student asked what learning math means if AI can do it better, and the host used Ecclesiastes to frame creative work as meaningful within a limited life. John Nay argued that human values and creativity will guide where abundant intelligence gets applied.

10/29/26: Ealy Vote Doom For GOP, Shock Polls In SC & KS, Bill Gates Dire AI Warning • Oct 29

  • A host says the robotics bottleneck is manufacturing capacity and safe deployment, not software, and estimates complex household or labor tasks could be about a year away. The host also cites Microsoft’s planned 60,000 job cuts and a Goldman Sachs finding linking workplace AI adoption with weaker employment growth and higher unemployment.
Also discussed on this episode: (15)

Elections (11)

  • Zachary Danini says Michigan may count its last 15-20% of ballots after 3 a.m., with late absentee votes from Detroit, Flint, Saginaw and Ann Arbor favoring Democrats. Michigan and Wisconsin still count some mail ballots late, while Pennsylvania and Georgia changed procedures after 2020 to count them earlier.
  • Zachary Danini cautions that early-vote counts do not reveal candidate choice, but says first-time and infrequent voters are disproportionately Democratic. In North Carolina, registered Democratic youth are turning out at five times the rate of registered Republican youth, a reversal from similar turnout in 2024.
  • Zachary Danini reports especially strong Hispanic early voting in Texas, North Carolina, Louisiana and Georgia, and says Hispanic voters could make up about one in four Texas voters. He sees similar, lower-confidence turnout patterns in Arizona, Nevada, Iowa and Kansas, while Democratic voter bases differ sharply by state.
  • Zachary Danini says North Carolina’s electorate could be up to 10 points bluer based on who is turning out, though registration does not prove vote choice. He says that electorate would have favored Harris by seven points, and cautions that this pattern is specific to North Carolina so far.
  • Zachary Danini separates turnout from persuasion: Democrats appear to be mobilizing their base and winning over some voters who supported Trump in 2024. He says the Senate remains competitive because Democrats must win two states among Iowa, Ohio, Texas and Alaska, all of which Trump carried by double digits.
  • Zachary Danini says candidate quality helped produce opposite outcomes in 2022: Republicans flipped New York’s 3rd District despite Biden winning it by double digits, while Joe Kent lost Washington’s 3rd District after a poor campaign. He cites Susan Collins as a strong candidate who can outperform her party’s environment.
  • A New York Times poll put South Carolina’s Senate race at 48-48 between Annie Andrews and Darlene Graham. The host says Andrews has a possible path through strong Black turnout and Republican weakness in the state’s west, but calls a win difficult and stresses that this is one poll.
  • The same New York Times polling showed Ashley Moody leading Angie Nixon in Florida, 50-44. The host described the result as a tighter race than expected, while noting that the poll alone does not establish the final state of the contest.
  • A New York Times poll had Peggy Flanagan ahead of Tafoya 54-40 in Minnesota, far beyond the three- or four-point race shown in previous polls. The host points to a possible national Democratic ballot advantage, anger over ICE activity and Republican underinvestment as reasons the race may not be close.
  • Nate Silver argues that a poor Republican midterm would make Trump a lame duck as the 2028 campaign begins, comparing the shift to George W. Bush after 2006. The hosts say Trump’s grip on the party may persist because he punishes Republicans who distance themselves, leaving them exposed whether they break with him or stay loyal.
  • The host compares the current outlook with 2018, when Democrats won the popular vote by about eight points while Trump was more popular on the economy. The host says today’s weak Trump approval, unpopular war, high fuel costs and lack of a Republican response could deepen Democratic gains.

AI Infrastructure (1)

  • Bill Gates predicts a chaotic 20-year transition before AI-driven abundance, with humanoid robots potentially arriving in two or three years or closer to eight. Gates says robots could eventually build homes, grow food and perform surgery, making human labor unnecessary if development continues without a major slowdown.

Labor (1)

  • The hosts argue that AI could eliminate entry-level work that teaches young people workplace skills and socializes them, while knowledge work may be the last large employment sector machines can replace. They warn that concentrated ownership points toward digital feudalism, even if automation could eventually free people from unwanted jobs.

Safety (1)

  • A cyberattack forced the University of New Mexico health system to divert ambulances, close clinics and stop patients from attending its Albuquerque hospital. The host says the breach’s connection to AI was unclear, but experts advise assuming hacks may be AI-enabled; the system runs the state’s only Level I trauma center.

History (1)

  • The hosts warn that the Industrial Revolution brought decades of labor conflict, unsafe conditions and social upheaval before workers secured protections and breaks. They argue that AI may leave workers with less leverage than earlier generations because employers could no longer need human labor at all.