Jim Jordan’s win tests the GOP’s populist turn
- Jim Jordan defeated Steve Scalise to lead House Republicans in the next Congress.
- His win signals populist strength, but critics question what he will deliver.
House Republicans chose Jim Jordan to lead them in the next Congress, defeating Steve Scalise in a contest that Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar described as a victory for the party’s populist wing. The Daily reported that Jordan, a Trump ally and chairman of the Judiciary Committee, is set to shape the party’s agenda.
Emily Jashinsky of Breaking Points cast Jordan as a longtime thorn in the Republican establishment, backed by Freedom Caucus figures. But the win does not settle whether he will meet the expectations of the populists who supported him. Jashinsky pointed to conservative critics who say Jordan did not follow through on promises to investigate the FBI and protect whistleblowers after Republicans won the House.
His record on technology draws similar criticism. Jordan has pressed Google over alleged online censorship, but Jashinsky said he later resisted antitrust bills supported by Ken Buck and Mike Lee. Critics, including Will Chamberlain in a 2022 post, have argued that Jordan’s hearings drew attention to censorship without backing measures that could curb Big Tech’s power.
Ryan Grim said Donald Trump’s dominance had frozen the fight between Republican insurgents and party leaders, while the party’s losses have started to thaw it. Jordan’s victory shows he can assemble support; as Jashinsky and Grim discussed, it does not yet show that he can satisfy either faction.
Source Intelligence
- Deep dive into what was said in the episodes
11/11/26: Jim Jordan Picked For House Minority Leader, Anthropic Plots $1.4 Trillion IPO, Pod Save Panelist Claims Gaza Hurt Abdul • Nov 11
- Jim Jordan defeated Steve Scalise for House Republican minority leader, a victory for the party’s populist wing. Jordan had defended a war with Iran in March, saying Americans could accept temporarily higher prices to stop Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.
- Emily said Jordan fought Google over alleged censorship but later resisted antitrust bills supported by Ken Buck and Mike Lee. A 2022 post by Will Chamberlain accused Jordan of using hearings to make consumers notice censorship while blocking measures that could curb Big Tech’s power.
- A War Room speaker argued that Jordan failed to act on FBI whistleblowers after Republicans won the House in 2022, and that Jordan had displaced Louie Gohmert from the Judiciary chairmanship. The speaker also said Jordan lost standing in the Freedom Caucus after repeatedly yielding to party leaders.
- Emily said AIPAC-affiliated individual donors had not previously ranked among Jordan’s top 20 campaign and leadership PAC donor groups, but did so this cycle. She flagged the shift as a developing story, while Ryan noted that Scalise was seen as more aligned with special interests and the establishment.
Also discussed on this episode: (12)
Elections (2)
- Ryan said Trump’s 2016 nomination froze the Republican civil war because insurgents had to pledge loyalty to Trump to avoid primary challenges. With Trump’s grip weakening, he expects renewed challenges to Republicans who became establishment figures; Emily put the Freedom Caucus at roughly 30 to 40 members at its peak.
- At a Pod Save America event, Joel Rubin argued that only two Senate candidates who used the word “genocide” performed poorly and that Israel-Palestine did not help Democrats politically. Ryan challenged the comparison, citing differences in opponents and campaign spending; the audience pushed back on Rubin.
Models (1)
- Dario Amodei said cancer, Alzheimer’s, heart disease, and mental illness could become relics within a decade, and argued that managing AI risks would help earn public trust. Ryan and Emily treated the promise as an aggressive pitch for Anthropic’s IPO.
AI Infrastructure (3)
- Anthropic’s filing put its prospective IPO valuation around $1.33 trillion, while the hosts described the target as roughly $1.4 trillion and said it was about $1 trillion below figures floated weeks earlier. The quoted share-price range was $70 to $78.
- Ryan criticized Anthropic’s IPO structure: its seven founders would retain control, while non-founder employees could sell 10% of their shares immediately, with 23 later opportunities for insiders to sell more. He said typical IPO lockups last at least six months and argued that the early exits shift downside risk to public investors.
- Ryan said Anthropic had raised hundreds of billions from private capital, had nearly exhausted private-credit funding, and faced close to $1 trillion in next-year compute and data-center liabilities against about $30 billion in revenue. Emily warned that losses and interconnected AI financing could make a company failure an economy-wide risk.
China (2)
- Emily and Ryan discussed allegations that NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang had a relationship with Alice Wong, a former executive investigated as a possible Chinese intelligence asset. The Information reported that Wong’s company, Shanghai Century Litong, enabled at least $7.5 billion in NVIDIA chip sales to China since 2023; the hosts stressed that espionage claims remained unresolved.
- Ryan said a short-seller report had alleged NVIDIA was evading US restrictions on chip sales to China, and questioned why the FBI and NSA had not acted if the claims were publicly available. Emily said incompetence was the likeliest explanation, while raising a possible double-agent scenario as speculation.
Markets (1)
- NVIDIA had fallen 24% over the previous month and represented more than 6% of the S&P 500, according to the hosts. Jim Cramer called it the cheapest it had been in 10 years and a buy; Ryan and Emily said the company’s size and dependence on Jensen Huang made the market unusually exposed to a single firm.
Middle East (2)
- Ryan described Gaza’s fourth winter with displaced Palestinians living in tents, flooding, and damaged belongings. He said Israel continued restricting tents over claims that tent poles could have dual use, while the World Food Program and World Central Kitchen had sharply reduced food aid since October.
- Ryan said Gaza’s displaced population had been pushed into low-lying areas where winter flooding is predictable, while damaged sewage treatment left raw sewage and rats among the tents. He reported rising respiratory illness and heart conditions, and said reconstruction equipment promised under the ceasefire had not arrived.
Regulation (1)
- Emily corrected an earlier description of the Tim Scott-Elizabeth Warren housing bill: Trump refused to sign it because it lacked the SAVE Act, but the bill became law. She said the correction did not change her point that the bill had been stalled despite JD Vance campaigning on it.
Public Schools Have a New Crisis: Not Enough Students • Nov 11
- The Daily reported that House Republicans chose Representative Jim Jordan to lead the party in the next Congress. Jordan, currently Judiciary Committee chairman and an ally of Donald Trump, is expected to help shape the party's agenda and defend the administration against congressional investigations.
Also discussed on this episode: (17)
Education (16)
- Sarah Mervosh says K-12 public enrollment fell in 30 states over the decade after about 2014. Los Angeles enrollment dropped 20%; Houston and Chicago 17% each, Dallas 13%, and Philadelphia 10%.
- Public school funding generally follows student counts, but expenses do not fall at the same pace: a smaller school still needs teachers, a principal, and a functioning building. Districts have cut bus routes, substitute teachers, and central-office staff before turning to school closures.
- School closures force districts to decide which students and neighborhoods bear the disruption. Because American schools remain segregated by race and class, closure plans also determine whose needs the district prioritizes.
- Pittsburgh public schools have lost about a quarter of their enrollment over the last decade. Mervosh links the decline to population loss, fewer births, more charter and homeschool options, and families leaving after prolonged pandemic-era school closures.
- The national fertility rate peaked in 2007, and the cohort born that year graduated high school in 2025. As those students leave public schools, districts face smaller incoming classes alongside the enrollment losses already underway.
- Pittsburgh's closure plan also redraws school boundaries and changes grade configurations to address inequity. The district serves a student body that is about two-thirds economically disadvantaged, roughly half Black, and about one-third white.
- Pittsburgh plans to eliminate elementary magnet schools and sharply reduce them at the middle-school level. Magnet schools use lotteries to admit students from across the city, often around specialties such as languages, arts, or science and technology.
- Supporters say magnets give families choice and bring students from different neighborhoods together; critics see them as a way for families to avoid neighborhood schools. Abigail Folds argues magnets also let children cross neighborhood and income boundaries instead of having their ZIP code determine their school.
- Pittsburgh's school board approved 12 closures in May by a 6-2 vote, with one member abstaining; the changes take effect after the current school year. Public hearings drew intense opposition, including from white parents who appeared in disproportionate numbers before a majority-Black board.
- School board president Gene Walker says consolidating under-enrolled schools would reduce building costs and let the district offer stronger programs. He points to a middle school unable to offer eighth-grade algebra, which can limit students' access to advanced high-school math and college preparation.
- Walker says the district wants every elementary school to offer art, music, STEM, physical education, and a foreign language beginning in third grade, with eighth-grade algebra available at every middle school. The plan asks families to trust that resources removed from closed buildings will reach schools that remain open.
- Parents describe small schools as places where teachers know their children, provide food, and support students with disabilities or behavioral needs. They worry that moves to larger schools could disrupt relationships, overwhelm students, and leave staff less prepared to support individual needs.
- Families also doubt that added programs alone will improve instruction or preserve academic rigor. SciTech parents fear that merging its selective science-and-technology magnet with neighborhood enrollment could weaken the curriculum, while families question whether incoming students will get enough support.
- Several hundred students, primarily from families with greater financial means, left Pittsburgh public schools during the current school year, though Mervosh says the reasons are unclear. One parent moved a third grader to private school early; the school's class size had doubled since the prior year, and the parent plans to move a second child.
- Some parents plan to stay because they value public education and want their children to learn alongside peers from different backgrounds; others say their children's needs come first. Many describe the district as on probation and say lost trust makes leaving feel more possible.
- Mervosh says Pittsburgh is betting that raising the floor for vulnerable students will strengthen the system, while risking the departure of higher-achieving and wealthier families. Across the country, districts have delayed enrollment decisions until they must choose between closures and unpopular staff reductions.
War (1)
- The Daily reported that House Republicans voted 211-204 to send impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to a committee, slowing consideration of eight charges, including an allegation tied to the Iran war. Representative Thomas Massie was the only Republican to oppose referral.

