Van Hollen challenges Schumer’s claim to Senate support
- Van Hollen says Schumer’s public count of Senate support is wrong.
- A secret-ballot leadership vote is scheduled for December 1, with an earlier vote possible.
- The challenge is built around Iran, Israel and frustration with party leadership.
Chris Van Hollen is disputing Chuck Schumer’s claim that he has enough support to remain Senate Democratic leader. Van Hollen says some senators Schumer’s allies listed as supporters have committed to him instead, turning the leadership contest into a test of whose vote count is right.
The challenge comes amid opposition to Schumer from several incoming Democratic senators, as well as Bernie Sanders and Alyssa Slotkin, who have signaled they don’t want him to continue. The 600,000-member Machinists union has also called for a new generation of leadership and urged Democrats to pass the PRO Act.
The caucus vote is scheduled for December 1, though an earlier vote could happen if members waive the usual timing through a secret ballot. Breaking Points’ hosts said Van Hollen needs 29 votes and cited a Drop Site count with 10 senators leaning toward him, 16 toward Schumer and 21 undecided. The Daily reported that Van Hollen says his support is growing.
The clearest policy contrast is over foreign affairs. Van Hollen wants to stop funding the Iran war and oppose military support for Israel. Breaking Points’ hosts contrasted that with Schumer’s record of hawkishness toward Iran. Van Hollen has also criticized Schumer for intervening in Democratic primaries alongside AIPAC and crypto interests.
The hosts argued the race could test not just those policy differences, but Schumer’s hold on party power: his leadership controls fundraising and assignments, yet they said he may be vulnerable because he is unpopular and could be a lame duck.
Source Intelligence
- Deep dive into what was said in the episodes
11/16/26: Trump Missing During FAA Meltdown, Dem Congressman Rejects Jeffries, Van Hollen Schumer Battle Erupts • Nov 16
- Chris Van Hollen challenged Chuck Schumer's claim to a locked-up Senate majority, saying some senators on Schumer's public list had committed to Van Hollen. The hosts said Van Hollen needs 29 votes and noted that the caucus election is scheduled for December 1, with an earlier vote possible through a secret-ballot waiver.
- Van Hollen’s strongest contrast with Schumer is foreign policy: he wants to stop funding the Iran war and oppose military support for Israel, while Schumer has a long record of hawkishness toward Iran. Van Hollen also faulted Schumer for intervening in Democratic primaries alongside AIPAC and crypto interests.
- The hosts argued that Schumer may be vulnerable because he is unpopular and could be a lame duck, while Jeffries faces less pressure in the House. They said presidential hopefuls fear alienating the Congressional Black Caucus and James Clyburn, and noted that at least 75 new House Democrats could disrupt leadership voting.
Also discussed on this episode: (11)
Safety (4)
- A nationwide FAA ground stop halted U.S. departures for several hours, canceled thousands of flights and caused delays across two days. The hosts described it both as the first and the second such shutdown since 9/11.
- The FAA blamed an overloaded network after a contractor installed a router in southern Arkansas, but the timing and scale left the cause unresolved. The hosts raised possible cyberattacks, an AI-system rollout, worldwide device hacks and a Microsoft Outlook outage as context, not established causes.
- Sean Duffy asked for $50 billion to modernize air traffic control, after officials cited a $30 billion request; Markwayne Mullin said there was 98 percent certainty an aging system caused the failure. The hosts cited GAO and NTSB concerns about implementation and oversight.
- Travelers faced sharply higher hotel and rental-car prices, while the Trump administration had changed a rule requiring airlines to provide hotel vouchers after disruptions. The hosts also cited a deadly Washington-area crash, repeated near misses and a prior air-traffic-control strain during a government shutdown.
Elections (3)
- Donald Trump made no public comment for nearly a day and a half during the shutdown, despite posting about Hollywood tax credits and a golf course. Sean Duffy said Trump was engaged privately; the hosts criticized the administration's praise of Trump and Markwayne Mullin's insistence on calling AI “SI.”
- Donald Leonard said he entered Congress-elect politics because he feared for democratic institutions and his young daughter's future. He argued that voters rejected the Democratic brand but elected challengers anyway, and cited a 16.6-point swing from a Trump-plus-10 district.
- Don Leonard said Ayanna Pressley would have his support for House leadership, despite disagreements over Medicare for All and abolishing ICE; Leonard favors Medicare for All who want it and replacing ICE with civilian law enforcement. He described both parties as products of a failed neoliberal political settlement.
Corruption (1)
- Don Leonard said he would withhold support for Hakeem Jeffries unless Democratic leadership committed to fighting political corruption, ending the Iran war and holding a vote on U.S. aid to Israel. He wants the party to back a 28th Amendment to overturn Citizens United in 2028.
Iran (1)
- Iran was reported to be attacking U.S. radar systems in Bahrain as the United States sent another aircraft carrier to the region. The hosts also said Trump had removed J.D. Vance from the foreign-policy portfolio.
Energy (1)
- The hosts said data centers accelerate carbon emissions while supporting Bitcoin mining and faster Google searches, and Don Leonard cited their environmental footprint as part of his concern about the future his daughter will inherit.
Big Tech (1)
- Tech leaders were reportedly asking NVIDIA to bring Jensen Huang back, while Huang was weighing whether a return was likely. The hosts previewed Anthropic going public that week and linked the developments to turmoil in the technology markets.
Finally, a Vaccine for Cancer • Nov 16
- Senator Chris Van Hollen said his challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader had growing support, disputing Schumer’s claim that he had enough votes. The contest was set for a secret-ballot vote on December 1.
Also discussed on this episode: (14)
Health (12)
- Nina Agrawal says the melanoma vaccine treats cancer after diagnosis and surgery, tailoring its instructions to each tumor’s mutations. Cancer varies from person to person, and some tumors evade immune detection.
- Researchers sequence each removed melanoma, select mutations likely to trigger immune recognition, then use mRNA to instruct the body to produce those proteins. The personalized vaccine can encode up to 34 mutations.
- The trial enrolled more than 1,100 patients with stage II, III, or IV melanoma after surgery, when little detectable disease remained but recurrence risk was high. Patients received nine doses three weeks apart, with mostly mild, short-lived side effects.
- Over two years, vaccine recipients were 42% less likely to have melanoma recur and were also less likely to develop metastatic disease. Nina Agrawal says the result is among the field’s largest advances, but longer follow-up is needed to assess survival.
- The melanoma vaccine was paired with an immune checkpoint inhibitor, which removes signals that suppress immune activity. Agrawal says taking these immune-system brakes off helped turn a vaccine-triggered response into a clinical benefit.
- Merck and Moderna plan to seek FDA approval for the melanoma vaccine. The trial’s two-year results do not establish long-term survival benefit, and researchers still need to learn whether the treatment works for other cancers.
- In the 1890s, surgeon William Coley injected tumors with bacterial mixtures after learning of a patient whose tumor shrank following an infection and fever. Some tumors regressed, possibly because bacteria activated an immune response, but the approach was later dismissed as quackery as radiation and chemotherapy emerged.
- Cancer immunotherapy gained momentum in the 1980s, with its first treatment approved in 1986. Genome sequencing later let researchers identify tumor-specific targets; sequencing an individual genome fell from a years-long, very costly project to hundreds of dollars and a process taking weeks.
- COVID-era manufacturing experience, especially at Moderna, helped make fast, scalable mRNA production possible. That capability gave researchers a practical way to manufacture vaccines customized to an individual tumor.
- Melanoma’s high mutation count may make it easier for the immune system to recognize than breast, colon, or pancreatic cancers. A small post-surgery pancreatic cancer study found fewer recurrences among vaccine recipients, and a larger randomized trial is underway.
- Personalized cancer vaccines are expected to be expensive because each dose is designed for one patient, while cancer therapies already often cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Researchers are exploring shared, off-the-shelf targets to reduce the need for individual tumor sequencing.
- Researchers are testing off-the-shelf vaccines for prevention or early interception in people at elevated risk, including people with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations, inherited colon-cancer syndromes, or precancerous polyps. Early studies are promising, but this approach remains years away and could fail.
Safety (2)
- A contractor replacing aging telecommunications equipment at an FAA site disrupted air-traffic network circuits, including radar, according to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. Officials said the disruption led to a nationwide ground stop on Friday night to protect travelers.
- Sean Duffy said the U.S. air-traffic control system needs urgent upgrades worth tens of billions of dollars. The ground stop exposed the safety risks of relying on aging network infrastructure.
It Could Happen Here Weekly 258 • Nov 14
- Several incoming Democratic senators and the 600,000-member Machinists union opposed Chuck Schumer continuing as Senate Democratic leader. Bernie Sanders and Alyssa Slotkin also signaled opposition; the union urged Democrats to pass the PRO Act and called for a new generation of leadership.
Also discussed on this episode: (56)
Climate (10)
- Carlos reports Puerto Rico’s water crisis began with years of mismanagement and neglected infrastructure, then worsened during a severe drought; officials blamed El Niño while leaving underlying repairs largely undone.
- Climate scientist Isati Sintrong describes drought as a cascading public-health and economic crisis that threatens water security, food production, and climate resilience; Puerto Rico’s governor declared an emergency and USDA issued a drought disaster declaration.
- Amira Odeh says Puerto Rico loses more than half the water moving through its system, largely through leaks and aging pipes; the losses persist despite a 2011 reduction target and exceed benchmarks Odeh cites for public systems.
- Amira Odeh argues that drought risk will grow as climate change worsens, while construction and deforestation threaten watersheds; she points to rooftop rainwater collection in Dominica and the British Virgin Islands as practical models Puerto Rico once used.
- Carlos says the proposed Esencia luxury development could consume almost as much water daily as the entire municipality of Cabo Rojo; the utility said it lacked capacity to supply the project, which experts warn would strain an already dry area.
- Carlos says Puerto Rico’s unapproved climate-adaptation plan proposes cutting water losses, reusing treated wastewater, planting trees, and restricting construction in flood-prone areas; political resistance and the fiscal control board have stalled implementation.
- David Forbes says Asheville’s post-Helene recovery exposed a divide between neighborhood mutual aid and government policies favoring landlords, tourism, and businesses; evictions resumed before water service returned, deepening displacement.
- Forbes says Asheville’s tourism economy had already driven high housing costs and low wages before Helene; officials later directed federal recovery money toward repairing a golf course and subsidized businesses while locals sought rental aid.
- Forbes says Asheville’s redevelopment plans ignored warnings that riverfront overdevelopment worsened flooding, while officials backed rebuilding the river district in place; he argues neighborhood organizing has forced some concessions and strengthened local networks.
- Forbes argues disaster preparation works best through trusted local networks that plan for water, food, and supply distribution before an emergency; his own preparations let him focus on checking on neighbors during later heavy rains.
Health (3)
- Dara Rivera says unpredictable shutoffs and inaccurate government updates disrupted daily routines and caused sustained emotional strain; her family stored about 30 gallons of water in jugs because their home lacked a cistern.
- Carlos says water outages created health risks from poor hygiene and unsafe water, while families paid for bottled water, prepared food, and truck deliveries; restaurants reported substantial weekly water costs despite operating limited services.
- Carlos says Puerto Rico’s aging Super Aqueduct and neglected pumps and reservoirs failed repeatedly, leaving hundreds of thousands with little or no water; his own neighborhood went without running water for roughly 10 days.
Corruption (3)
- Carlos says the government responded faster when failures affected tourism and businesses, dispatching water trucks and the National Guard; roughly a third of Puerto Rico’s residents live below the poverty line and struggled to afford emergency water.
- Carlos says the utility paid private companies $50 million over two decades without stopping deterioration, while infrastructure repair receives a shrinking budget share; sediment also makes a quarter of reservoir capacity unusable.
- Forbes says Asheville’s water system had long been neglected, including a pricing structure that charged major users less per unit as they consumed more; he argues the policy encouraged overuse by breweries, manufacturers, and a hospital.
Regulation (8)
- Carlos argues that household cisterns and other preparedness measures shift responsibility from government to individuals, widening inequality; a 2024 law requires government buildings to collect rainwater, but reporting found no apparent implementation.
- Carlos says Morovis sued the public utility over prolonged failures to deliver water, arguing that the outages violated the municipality’s constitutional rights; a 2026 settlement requires infrastructure projects by January 2028.
- Forbes says Asheville’s city government used the disaster to push through a Business Improvement District after withdrawing earlier concessions; downtown residents now pay a tax to a Chamber of Commerce-controlled front group.
- Forbes says Asheville shut down citizen boards after the storm, raised property taxes, expanded police spending, and increased senior officials’ pay; he argues those choices diverted resources from residents and recovery needs.
- Rose says the merger settlement relies on weak behavioral promises, including a film-release quota and an editorial board selected by Skydance’s controlling owner, rather than structural remedies such as requiring the sale of CNN.
- Rose says the merger’s force-majeure clause could let Skydance abandon commitments during broadly defined events such as economic downturns or labor unrest, leaving the settlement difficult to enforce.
- Rose says the Trump administration’s approval of the deal followed political pressure and a payment to Trump connected to a 60 Minutes dispute; he argues concentrated media ownership and political favoritism weaken public access to information.
- The Senate passed the bipartisan BAAJA permitting bill with roughly three-quarters of the vote. The host argues it weakens Indigenous treaty rights and environmental protections, including the Endangered Species Act and NEPA, and could enable data centers and pipelines as well as green-energy projects.
Privacy (2)
- Forbes says Asheville expanded drone, camera, and police surveillance after Helene, including surveillance used to target homeless people; public pressure forced City Hall to cancel a Flock contract, though officials left open the possibility of restoring it.
- Rose says Oracle’s investment in TikTok’s U.S. venture gives Oracle access to user data and oversight of the algorithm; accusations of censorship followed the ownership change, though he says they remain difficult to prove conclusively.
Censorship (2)
- Forbes says Asheville police used pepper balls against people leaving bars in queer nightlife areas, citing past crime rather than an immediate threat; officials also redirected debris from a historically Black neighborhood after residents mobilized.
- James Stout says a Galatasaray jersey image resembling yellow body bags reopened painful memories for Kurdish people and exposed unresolved tensions between Turkey and the PKK during a peace process.
Society (1)
- Forbes says local bookstores, churches, a homeless-support group, and Asheville’s Register of Deeds helped coordinate relief when larger nonprofits fell short; mutual-aid networks and labor organizing continued after the immediate disaster response.
Media (4)
- Kevin Foster says Paramount’s acquisition of Warner Bros. concentrated major film, television, and news properties under Skydance; a state lawsuit settled for promises to release films, while planned cost cuts threaten workers and theaters.
- Screenwriter Jake Hart says consolidation reduces writing jobs, wages, and diversity of voices; after the 2023 Hollywood strikes, studios cut production, writers’ rooms, and the number of shows they bought.
- Adam Rose warns that David Ellison’s control of CNN and CBS gives one owner influence over 40% of the White House television press pool, reducing the number of independent cameras recording the president.
- Rose says media consolidation threatens news archives and historical memory, as layoffs and restrictive licensing can block access to footage; he warns that concentrated ownership makes it easier to shape what future audiences can see.
Markets (1)
- Rose says the merger’s financing looked financially unsound and could attract foreign investors and Elon Musk; he also argues Oracle’s surveillance and defense businesses could benefit from media narratives favoring expanded policing and military spending.
History (2)
- Andrew Siege compares Gaetano Bresci’s 1900 killing of Italy’s king with Luigi Mangione’s 2024 killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, arguing that attacks on symbolic individuals leave the institutions they represent intact.
- Siege says Bresci’s politics grew from poverty, factory work, and participation in a connected Italian-American anarchist movement; Mangione’s available writings instead linked personal experiences and grievances to the U.S. health-insurance system.
Social Media (1)
- Siege says Mangione’s case generated broad online discussion and public sympathy, while Bresci’s killing intensified repression of anarchists; neither assassination changed the underlying institutions, though corporate executives increased security.
Safety (1)
- Siege argues assassination removes the actor from organizing and can give the state grounds to expand policing, surveillance, and restrictions on protest; he favors building movements and alternatives that address the structures producing violence.
Diplomacy (1)
- Stout says the Trump administration has moved closer to Myanmar’s military junta, holding direct government meetings and setting U.S. goals around visa overstays, scam compounds, trade, and countering Chinese influence, without mentioning democracy or political prisoners.
China (1)
- Stout says the U.S. Burma strategy treats fiscal federalism and territorial demarcation partly as routes to rare-earth access; scam compounds hold people against their will, and the FBI has recently increased action against them.
Iran (1)
- The host says the State Department sanctioned three alleged middlemen accused of helping Iran obtain Chinese and Russian man-portable air-defense systems, including through fake Nigerian end-user certificates.
Immigration (3)
- Portsmouth, England, granted its RNLI lifeboat crew the city’s highest civic honor after councillors heard crews and their children had faced abuse over rescues that include migrants in danger at sea. Reform UK councillors abstained.
- Trump said immigration enforcement may have been “too tough” and floated a deal allowing some long-term undocumented residents to stay, while blaming the crackdown for hurting Republicans. The same week, he promoted Stephen Miller to chief of staff, consolidating influence for an adviser associated with hardline immigration policies.
- Washington’s Western District U.S. Attorney’s Office said a surge of immigration habeas petitions had overwhelmed its capacity, so it would stop appearing in every case. If prosecutors do not appear within seven court days, judges may decide petitions based on the filings submitted by detainees.
Labor (2)
- A general strike in Spain coincided with the 90th anniversary of the Battle of Madrid, when the Graphic Arts and Hairdressers battalions helped hold off Franco’s forces.
- Zoran Mamdani has asked union leaders about endorsements and potential candidates to build support for a progressive labor standard-bearer before the next election. He met with UAW president Sean Fain, whom the host describes as a leading possible candidate.
Elections (3)
- CNN projected Scott Colom to win Mississippi’s Senate race by about 4,000 votes, which would make him the first Black person elected to statewide office there since Reconstruction; Mississippi has no recount rule. Alaska’s count remained unresolved, with a possible instant runoff.
- Republicans chose Jim Jordan, a co-founder of the House Freedom Caucus, as House minority leader beginning in 2027 after Mike Johnson said he would not seek another term. A host cited reports that Jordan knew of, and ignored, sexual abuse allegations involving more than 100 Ohio State wrestlers.
- Trump blamed Republicans’ midterm loss partly on being absent from the ballot, unpopular candidates, Iran, and rising gasoline prices, while boasting about the stock market and wealth creation. He denied a reported $3 billion increase in his net worth; hosts argued market gains did not ease costs for people without assets.
War (4)
- Thomas Massie introduced eight impeachment articles against Pete Hegseth, including allegations of unlawful wars, civilian harm, extrajudicial killings, and threats against Senator Mark Kelly. The House rejected advancing the measure 204 to 205; three articles concerned the War Powers Act and Iran.
- Trump said he would pardon “tremendous numbers” of people before leaving office and might pardon himself, and suggested he could endorse a 2028 presidential candidate. He also claimed victory in Iran and said 18 people had died, while Defense Department figures put Iran War deaths at 23 since February 2026.
- El Salvador sent roughly 2,500 soldiers to Haiti after four Salvadoran troops were reported kidnapped, but only about 200 fell under the UN gang force’s mandate. Salvadoran troops joined a strike that reportedly killed at least 20 people; Haiti’s drone campaign had already killed 1,243 people, including children.
- Robert Evans and Carlos describe Haiti as a testing ground for Bukele’s regional military ambitions and Eric Prince’s private-security model, with no clear plan for ending gang control or restoring elections. The hosts say Haitians have little voice in decisions and note that Trump sent immigrants to El Salvador’s CECOT prison.
Nation-State (1)
- Trump called Venezuela a possible U.S. “territory” and boasted about taking billions from it; a New York Times report said the U.S. received more than $12 billion from Venezuelan natural-resource exports in the year’s first nine months. Trump also said a Ukraine deal was close and denied knowing who slowed Ukraine’s Starlink speeds.
Chips (2)
- Robert Evans reports that U.S. officials suspected NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang had a relationship with alleged Chinese intelligence asset Alice Huang of Megaspeed, a firm suspected of moving restricted chips. He says Commerce officials constrained the investigation after NVIDIA lawyers contacted a Trump appointee; the inquiry later moved to the Justice Department.
- NVIDIA reported $7.9 billion in China-headquartered customer revenue, while Robert Evans cites a separate estimate of $43 billion in indirect China sales and a $7.5 billion chip purchase by Shanghai Century Letong. Huang resigned after reports of another affair; NVIDIA shares fell sharply amid the allegations.


